Why Victims of Human Trafficking Fear Law Enforcement

Understanding Fear of Law Enforcement

Published Sep 20, 2024, J. Patrick Power

For Law Enforcement & Outreach Professionals

In the course of your work, you may encounter someone who seems evasive, hostile, or even combative. You might suspect criminal behavior—or see it outright. But what if that person isn’t a criminal at all?

What if they’re a victim of human trafficking, and everything you’ve been trained to detect is also what they’ve been taught to fear?

In the anti-trafficking field, we often ask: Why don’t victims just ask for help? Why don’t they run? The most pressing answer is this: many victims are afraid of us—afraid of law enforcement, outreach workers, and anyone who might challenge the trafficker’s control.

This fear isn’t irrational. It’s rooted in experience—and often in reality. Two reasons rise above the rest and deserve our focused attention.

1. Fear of Arrest and Criminalization

To a trafficking victim, the justice system doesn’t always look like a way out. It looks like a trap.

Many victims are forced into illegal activities—prostitution, drug smuggling, theft, or fraud. These aren’t incidental; they’re built into the business model of exploitation. And traffickers know how to use them as tools of control: “If you leave, the cops will arrest you. You’ll go to jail, not me.”

Worse still, that prediction sometimes comes true.

Victims of sex trafficking, for instance, are routinely arrested during sting operations targeting prostitution. Survivors of labor trafficking may be caught using forged documents they were given—or coerced into stealing from employers or clients. In every one of these cases, the victim’s criminal activity is a symptom of their exploitation, not a choice freely made.

What this means for you:

Your initial encounter may not look like a victim scenario. You might see someone with an alias, a long rap sheet, or a hostile attitude. But scratch the surface, and a different story often emerges—one of threats, beatings, coercion, and fear.

What you can do:

Apply trauma-informed questioning.

Look for red flags of coercion and control.

Be cautious about jumping to prosecution, especially for non-violent offenses.

When appropriate, advocate for diversion programs or referrals to victim services.

2. Mistrust Rooted in Past Experiences

Imagine growing up in a community where the police are rarely seen as protectors—where every interaction with authority is tinged with risk. That’s the reality for many trafficking victims.

Whether it’s systemic racism, economic marginalization, or previous encounters with corrupt or abusive officers (at home or abroad), many survivors carry deep mistrust of law enforcement.

Consider:

A Black teenager raised in a neighborhood where police presence means stop-and-frisk or worse.

An immigrant woman trafficked for domestic labor who fled a country where the police were part of the trafficking ring.

A survivor of child sex trafficking who was treated like a criminal when she was 15—booked, charged, and made to feel like she chose what was done to her.

These aren’t hypotheticals. They are real stories, echoed in survivor interviews, case files, and courtroom testimony.

This kind of mistrust isn’t erased by good intentions or a kind tone—it has to be earned over time.

What you can do:

Understand that fear of police may be learned behavior based on real danger.

Avoid moral judgment or skepticism if someone is hesitant, defensive, or refuses help.

Partner with community-based organizations or survivor-led programs—people who may already have trust where you don’t yet.

Show consistency. One respectful, compassionate officer can begin to shift a victim’s perception—but it may take many more to make it stick.

Final Thought

Human trafficking is about power and control. Traffickers isolate, intimidate, and weaponize the very systems meant to help. If we’re not careful, our roles can be used to reinforce their narrative: “The cops won’t help you—they’ll hurt you.”

But we can flip that script. It starts by seeing not just what’s in front of us, but what might be behind it.

In every moment of hesitation, hostility, or silence, there could be a chance to rebuild trust—and maybe, just maybe, to save a life.

Back to previous page